James David Garner

[Fitzcarraldo]

Re: James Garner

Pretty sure Boro will want a deal for Spence that's majority cash up front, they've already been over spending and Wilder will want to spend more (as always)

Sure, but even in this scenario and in budgeting terms we only express an amortised proportion.

 

[cheapseats]

Re: James Garner

Can't see a permanent deal, but another loan should be possible if we get promoted. Though then we're helping develop the player of a direct rival

3 years on loan to the same club??!!!. That must be some sort of record.

Having spent all my time arguing that Jimmy won't get a chance at ManU I now think different and I think he will go back next year and get a shot. Ten Hag will know the value of a few home grown lads in there-its always been the Manure way and I think Jimmy is desperate for a shot at it such that if you offered him 10-20 games including as a sub in a season I think he'd take it.

 

[Strummer]

Re: James Garner

3 years on loan to the same club??!!!. That must be some sort of record.

Having spent all my time arguing that Jimmy won't get a chance at ManU I now think different and I think he will go back next year and get a shot. Ten Hag will know the value of a few home grown lads in there-its always been the Manure way and I think Jimmy is desperate for a shot at it such that if you offered him 10-20 games including as a sub in a season I think he'd take it.

Wouldn’t be three years though?

Two-season loans are quite common in Germany; as I’ve posted before, FC Bayern „legend“ Philipp Lahm earned his stripes during a two-season loan to my local side.

 

[GreeksBearingGifts]

Re: James Garner

Garner will not be in the Championship next season.

Neither will you.

I still think a buy (with a substantial sell-on clause) is feasible. Not by any chance an easy task, but feasible.

 

[Bungle]

Re: James Garner

Neither will you.

I still think a buy (with a substantial sell-on clause) is feasible. Not by any chance an easy task, but feasible.

Agreed. £12m plus 40% sell on


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[cheapseats]

Re: James Garner

Wouldn’t be three years though?

Two-season loans are quite common in Germany; as I’ve posted before, FC Bayern „legend“ Philipp Lahm earned his stripes during a two-season loan to my local side.

Not sure about your maths Strummer-last season and this season equals two seasons. If we were to get him again next year that's another season equalling three....

 

[Cortez the Killer]

Re: James Garner

Incredible that we spent £13.2m on Carvalho really.

Sent from my SM-A920F using Tapatalk

 

[JohnnyCarey]

Re: James Garner

I can't see any way that Jimmy won't be in the Man U squad next season. He's highly valued by the coaching staff, who will be advocating for him big time. He has proven himself over two seasons of man's football in a tough league. There's a new manager who has a record of bringing on young players. And disgruntled Man U fans would be appeased by seeing someone who has come up through the ranks get a chance. Alas for us, I'd be amazed if he's not given a chance there.

 

[Otis Redding]

Re: James Garner

Not sure about your maths Strummer-last season and this season equals two seasons. If we were to get him again next year that's another season equalling three....

He arrived in January of the 2020-21 season.

 

[cheapseats]

Re: James Garner

He arrived in January of the 2020-21 season.

Sorry I thought we had him on a full year loan that first season, didn't realise it was only a January signing.

Apologies Strummer!

 

[Thomas]

Re: James Garner

I can't see any way that Jimmy won't be in the Man U squad next season. He's highly valued by the coaching staff, who will be advocating for him big time. He has proven himself over two seasons of man's football in a tough league. There's a new manager who has a record of bringing on young players. And disgruntled Man U fans would be appeased by seeing someone who has come up through the ranks get a chance. Alas for us, I'd be amazed if he's not given a chance there.

All depends on the new lad coming in anyway and if he fits that system. They’re gonna throw everything at signing that Dutch midfielder from Barca so we’ll see where he ends up in the depth chart.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Eddie Yates]

Re: James Garner

Man U will look at him in pre season & then spunk 100s of millions on some overpriced overhyped shite players & we'll get him back

 

[cheapseats]

Re: James Garner

Man U will look at him in pre season & then spunk 100s of millions on some overpriced overhyped shite players & we'll get him back

I hope so, but something tells me Ten Hag has more about him than that....

I did see a stat that showed that Manure are the biggest spending side in the premier league, beating all the "usual" suspects. That being the case they are hopeless at getting it right. Their biggest periods of success have always coincided with a spine that is home grown...

 

[HappyHappyJoyJoy]

Re: James Garner

Not at his usual standard last night,but we can forgive him that.

Hope the hammy's OK, he'll love all the wide open spaces at Wembley

 

[Alf-engelos Mindminackers]

Re: James Garner

Not at his usual standard last night,but we can forgive him that.

Hope the hammy's OK, he'll love all the wide open spaces at Wembley

Think both he and Yates need the rest which is coming their way.

 

[congo_red_49]

Re: James Garner

Think both he and Yates need the rest which is coming their way.

They’re not the only ones that need a rest.

 

[Alf-engelos Mindminackers]

Re: James Garner

They’re not the only ones that need a rest.

Even if his hammy is slightly twinging, and Yates shoulder slightly aggravating him, I'm glad their getting it.

 

[duncanmckenzie]

Re: James Garner

Just before Colin Frey finally finished last night at 11.30pm he mentioned that Jimmy Garner was still on the pitch. Having one last look at the ground or taking it in because it's where he feels at home?

 

[gamble]

Re: James Garner

Just before Colin Frey finally finished last night at 11.30pm he mentioned that Jimmy Garner was still on the pitch. Having one last look at the ground or taking it in because it's where he feels at home?

Tbf they only left the pitch about 1115.

Sent from my SM-G998B using Tapatalk

 

[Flaggers]

Re: James Garner

Just before Colin Frey finally finished last night at 11.30pm he mentioned that Jimmy Garner was still on the pitch. Having one last look at the ground or taking it in because it's where he feels at home?

There was a picture being posed for - the Nottingham boys - worrall Yates Jonno.

Garner got himself in the picture.

 

[marshal99]

Re: James Garner

Just before Colin Frey finally finished last night at 11.30pm he mentioned that Jimmy Garner was still on the pitch. Having one last look at the ground or taking it in because it's where he feels at home?

this is garner last game at the city ground, probably last look. He might be fond of forest but his desire lies in breaking into man yoo first team.

 

[mysteryduck]

Re: James Garner

3 years on loan to the same club??!!!. That must be some sort of record.

Having spent all my time arguing that Jimmy won't get a chance at ManU I now think different and I think he will go back next year and get a shot. Ten Hag will know the value of a few home grown lads in there-its always been the Manure way and I think Jimmy is desperate for a shot at it such that if you offered him 10-20 games including as a sub in a season I think he'd take it.

3 years on loan is definitely unusual, but I wouldn't rule it out. Would be a very big call for Ten Hag, who'll be under big pressure immediately, to use him with any kind of regularity.

The equation could easily be play a full year of Premier league football for Forest vs play for Man U in the league cup and come off the bench in the league a few times

 

[HBB]

Re: James Garner

this is garner last game at the city ground, probably last look. He might be fond of forest but his desire lies in breaking into man yoo first team.

Might not be his last game at the City Ground if he starts playing for Man United he can visit when we're in the Prem!!!!

 

[Listen 'ere young man]

Re: James Garner

If Forest gain promotion, it would suit both parties to extend the loan to another year.

Don't think Man U will be dropping a player with no Premier league experience straight int their first team. Their manager will be under pressure for immediate results rather than long term rebuilds.

Sent from my SM-F926B using Tapatalk

 

[Rzar]

Re: James Garner

If they don't sign midfielders then Garner will be involved for them, but there is no way they don't go into next season not spending a fortune on midfielders. The current crop Man U have are pathetic. They will sign Rice or somebody.