• All - as you will understand, the forum is exceptionally busy at this time. The admins and moderators simply don't have time to read every post in every thread. Could you PLEASE use the "Report" option below a post to flag any content that you feel we need to be aware of. We'll review everything reported as a priority and deal with it accordingly. Thank you.

Ryan James Yates (sponsored by Raymondo Ponté)

What do you want with your Humble Pie?


  • Total voters
    34
  • Poll closed .

MASE

Up-Front
I will never understand why he receives so much criticism from some fans - it’s like they have to stick to their narrative of bashing him all the time, such a bizarre take.
Its really not that difficult to grasp. There will always be an argument as to whether heart & desire wins over technical ability. That argument never goes away whilst Ryan Yates occupies such a key position in a team that's struggled like f*** for a long time. one good season in the championship doesnt feel like a huge amount to show for it.

Played well last night though & your clearly helping Yates when you pair him with some dynamism, which Danillo showed last night. A relatively minor point, but his presence in & around the 18yd box has become largely pointless as he converts nothing.

Worth his place currently, no doubt.
 

'mist rollin in'

First Team Squad
Its really not that difficult to grasp. There will always be an argument as to whether heart & desire wins over technical ability. That argument never goes away whilst Ryan Yates occupies such a key position in a team that's struggled like f*** for a long time. one good season in the championship doesnt feel like a huge amount to show for it.

Played well last night though & your clearly helping Yates when you pair him with some dynamism, which Danillo showed last night. A relatively minor point, but his presence in & around the 18yd box has become largely pointless as he converts nothing.

Worth his place currently, no doubt.

Good point - Sangare is probably a more technically gifted player than Yates but has shown nothing, so I'm always going to prefer a player who shows desire even if the quality might not always be there. Also an element with Yates that he's the last player standing of that promotion team and has come through the ranks of the academy, which I understand are irrelevant points, but I always think it's important to have a player who can communicate to other players what certain games mean to fans.
 

Redemption

Agenda Benda
In the Nuno era, Yates picked more than any other MF.

Yet another manager choosing his deficiency over other players.

One coach having that blind spot, I would get. Every coach he plays for falling under his spell, he must have something?
 
Last edited:

Red Echo

Youth Team
In the Nuno era, Yates picked more than any other MF.

Yet another manager choosing his deficiency over other players.

One coach having that blind spot, I would get. Every coach he plays for falling under his spell, he must have something?
He doesn't get enough credit for his footballing brain. It'd be easy for a player to get carried away performing his, er, 'agricultural' role in the team, but it never feels like he's at risk of being sent off. The opposite is true - he's out there consistently winning fouls in the Best League In The World™ like a puppet master pulling the strings.

If building a team is all about balance then Yates is just as vital as any flair player, and every Forest manager he's worked under has recognised that that. Long may it continue.
 

Gyros Peter

Sauce salad?
Whilst not getting us very far.
What's the bar? He got us promoted, secured out status last year and hopefully will this.

I agree with your previous post re Danilo btw.

For me in an ideal world Sangare is your Yates upgrade, but he hasn't been. One day perhaps? I'd back Yates in that fight, but suspect another might get added.
 

Red Echo

Youth Team
Whilst not getting us very far.
The year we were promoted was the first (arguably the second) year in which he became a starter for practically every game, so I'm not sure what you mean there.

I don't quite think it was Yates who was holding Diakhaby, Jenkinson, and Freeman back from glory in previous years.

As for the present day, for as long as Forest are trying to be a dogged, counter-attacking team, his value and contribution is clear to see. If a manager eventually comes along who plays possession football with a high line, perhaps not, but that future is nothing but a dream at the minute.
 

congo_red_49

Ale Ape
For me in an ideal world Sangare is your Yates upgrade, but he hasn't been. One day perhaps? I'd back Yates in that fight, but suspect another might get added.
Indeed. If you look back over the posts in Sangare's thread, he was supposed to be the missing piece that would allow our midfield to control games and allow us to play a more possession based game.
Whilst some of that might just be the over-hyping of a new talent, the fact that he's been an utter passenger most of the time he's been on the field, means that, at this stage, just being a slight upgrade on Yates would be something.
 

JonnoSnr

Youth Team
Probably has the lowest ceiling of our midfielders and at times can clearly look out of his depth, he can take an extra touch or an extra split second to do something which you just don't get at this level.

Fair play to him for making the absolute most of his ability though, if the likes of Marlon King, Abdoun, Carvalho, Ishmael Miller plus many many more had even a smidgen of Yates' drive and will to get better over the years perhaps we'd have established ourselves in the prem long ago.

He's certainly good to have in the squad but if you fast forward 12 months from now and we're still a Premier League club with Ryan Yates starting every game in midfield then we could be in for another long struggle.
 

Gyros Peter

Sauce salad?
Probably has the lowest ceiling of our midfielders and at times can clearly look out of his depth, he can take an extra touch or an extra split second to do something which you just don't get at this level.

Fair play to him for making the absolute most of his ability though, if the likes of Marlon King, Abdoun, Carvalho, Ishmael Miller plus many many more had even a smidgen of Yates' drive and will to get better over the years perhaps we'd have established ourselves in the prem long ago.

He's certainly good to have in the squad but if you fast forward 12 months from now and we're still a Premier League club with Ryan Yates starting every game in midfield then we could be in for another long struggle.
I agree, and while I think technically he has improved I'll also add that every year of his career a similar thing has been said, so fully expect him to step up again.
 

JonnoSnr

Youth Team
I agree, and while I think technically he has improved I'll also add that every year of his career a similar thing has been said, so fully expect him to step up again.
Depends how you define stepping up I suppose. In pure numbers he's not scored since promotion and has 3 assists in that time. I understand his game isn't necessarily about goal contributions but prior to that in the Championship he was chipping in with a decent number of goals.

Being picked in the Premier League and be able to consistently play well in the Premier League are two very different things.
 

Flaggers

May not be the best moderator on LTLF, but he's...
LTLF Minion
Whilst not getting us very far.
Remind me which league we got into for the first time in 23 years the other season?
 

Gyros Peter

Sauce salad?
Depends how you define stepping up I suppose. In pure numbers he's not scored since promotion and has 3 assists in that time. I understand his game isn't necessarily about goal contributions but prior to that in the Championship he was chipping in with a decent number of goals.

Being picked in the Premier League and be able to consistently play well in the Premier League are two very different things.
What I mean is that he'll hit those numbers and prove us wrong. (In that I agree with your post that we need better but can also see a world where he becomes that)
 

Larry Lansbury

Viv Anderson
The pairing in Centre mid is key. Yesterday combo of Danillo and Yates worked so well. Danillo more box to box and with touch of class, Yates loving the battles in middle and on edge of our box, putting his head and body in. Commentator called him a stunt man after another reply of him putting his body on the line!
 

Baronvon

Jack Burkitt
Immense last night. If he hadn't made that interception when Aina gave the ball away in a dangerous position, we could have easily gone on to lose that game.
 

stockers

Jack Armstrong
Our MF should really be from Danilo, Dominguez and Yates.. Maybe next season Sangare might step up but at the moment we look like we're playing with 10 men on the pitch when he plays and you can't do that in the Prem..
 

ColwickReds

A. Trialist
Probably been said already but Yates played a great game yesterday. I thought he was 8/10 at the time in the ground but having watched the match twice already in full on the tele he was even better than that. Lost count of the amount of times I shouted "well in Yatesey!".
 
Top Bottom