Kier
Banned
Winnits said:Whilst he had a beneficial short-term impact, the long term damage he caused wasn't worth the aggro... without re-opening the pointless 'did Hart deserve to go' debate, I do think that we could have, and should have, appointed a more sensible long-term option at the time with the same short-term benefits.
Agree with that, even though other managers we've had (Megson and Platt) did far more damage then he did).
It would not surprise me though if he had a good short-term impact on Newcastle though. Alan Shearer did sum up his appointment quite aptly stating if he'd named 500 potential candidates Kinnear wouldn't have been on the list lol