At the risk of raising a couple of pairs of eyebrows for even daring to post this, I believe that authentic documentary evidence charting the origins of NFFC dates at least as far back as that of the seemingly unquestioned "oldest professional football club in the world".
Interestingly noted that Sam Weller was born in Hucknall Torkard, the team the Garibaldi's were playing. Probably nothing in it, but it's fun delving about the census. Which I did after asking the question, something I should really have done before. Just laziness on my part. As noted by Red til Dead I couldn't find a G Widdowson in Levi Widdowson's family (he Sam's Dad) in either 1851 or '61. I do a bit of family history on my own family so have an Ancestry sub.
I did find that there was a pub in Notts in 1862 called the General Garibaldi in Bridlesmith Gate near the Lace Market. It was run by a Thomas Smith. Perhaps that was where the Nottingham Garibaldi Cricket Club was based. There appears to have been another cricket club with Garibaldi in its name. Thw Worcester Journal dated 3rd November 1866, reports that the Garibaldi Cricket Club had an end of season dinner at the Angel Hotel Pershore.
Giuseppe Garibaldi was an immensely popular figure in the UK (and throughout Europe) in the 1850s and '60s so it's entirely possible that all these different Garibaldi clubs were unrelated.
He had a cracking beard too, of which some of the current Forest squad have squeezed out pale imitations.
There are many historical reports that the original founding members of NFFC chose Garibaldi Red (originally for caps, not shirts at first) in tribute to Signor Garibaldi's "Red Shirts" party.
It doesn't seem too popular in the Nottingham area that's for sure. I've just gone through the back 2 pages of the Notts Guardian for the whole of 1865 and there is no ,mention of Forest and very little of County other than playing a couple of games against Sheffield (Nofolk probably but not stated I don't thisk). The first game reported was either on on Jan 2nd 1865 or December 26th 1864. The back two pages appear to have the sport and local news so seemed the likeliest to have what I was looking for. I will go through the same for the first half of 1866 and see what I find there.
However Here is some background on the period as remembered from going through those pages fot 1865.
The country and in fact much of Europe was in the grip of a cattle plague.
Nottingham was subjected to 3 small earth tremours on January 2nd
View attachment 9052
According to the paper, there were over 2 million accidents in 1864. Over 10,000 resulted in death. A search showed the figures for 2010 were 1.2m accidents and under 300 dead as a result. It seems H&S works!
There used to be an annual pony race at Heanor.
They loved poetry - every paper seems to have at least one poem. There was an extract of a long one by pharmasist (I think that wass his job), F R Goodyer called The Modern Voyager; or, Barney Flinn the Circumnavigator which reminded me a little of an eary version of the style of Stanley Holloway, but with a Notts accent.
A man swam something like half a mile to a mile smoking a cigar and wearing a straw hat. (It doesn't say why though!)
The mines were incredibly dangerous then. They were still using naked candles so there were many explosions. If the mines weren't exploding, they were caving in or people were falling down the shafts.
They must have felt very stressed as there were always lots of ads purporting to help people to calm their nerves and help them sleep.
Partially related to the above there were a lot of suicides and accidental poisonings. A number of babies died from laudnum overdoses because there mothers put too much on their dummies.
There were a lot of crimes where people stole food - cheese, eggs, apples and chickens in particular.
The railways didn't seem a particularly safe place to travel. Several crashes were reported and a number of trains blew up! That said, there were many instances of children putting stones on the tracks - it seems little changes there then except the stones may be bigger now.
The papers carry lots of reports of murders from around the country and often in fairly graphic detail.
To travel by train to London from Nottingham cost 23s (£1.15) 1st class, 17s (85p) 2nd class, and 10s 5d (52p) 3rd class. The journey took 4 to 4 and a half hours.
Nottingham to Mansfield cost 2s (10p), 1s 6d (7.5p) or 1s (5) for 1st, 2nd or 3rd class and took between 40 minutes and a hour.
Giuseppe Garibaldi visited the UK in 1864. He doesn't seem to have got north of Bedford on the visit but together with newspaper stories may explain why he would be in the minds of the founders -http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/jun/03/garibaldi-london-visit-editorial
Hope you find the above interesting
Garibaldi’s exploits made him an international hero during his lifetime. An account from April 1864 describes one of his visits to London:
The reaction he provoked among workers and trade unions began to worry the government. It eventually ordered him out of the country – and Queen Victoria made clear she regarded this as good riddance.